Paul Newman's Four Daytonas: A Love Story Engraved on the Caseback

From the 6239 that sold for $17.75 million to the Big Red gifted for their 25th wedding anniversary, Paul Newman's watches tell the story of a couple, a passion for racing, and the power of provenance on the market.

On October 26, 2017, in New York, the room at Phillips held its breath. A steel Rolex Daytona, estimated at around $1 million, was hammered down for $17,752,500 including fees. At the time, it was the most expensive wristwatch ever sold at auction. Yet its original owner did not care much for watches. What Paul Newman wore on his wrist was, above all, a few words from his wife, actress Joanne Woodward, engraved on the caseback.

For Newman's watchmaking history comes down to four Daytona models, three of which were gifts from Joanne, each bearing an increasingly insistent message. Following them one by one tells the story of a couple, a passion for motor racing, and the birth of one of the most speculative markets in watchmaking.

The 6239, or a Wife's Anxiety

In the late 1960s, Newman discovered racing while filming Winning (1969), a movie dedicated to motorsport. Joanne Woodward chose a watch designed for the track: a Rolex Cosmograph Daytona reference 6239, manufactured in 1968. On the back, she had “DRIVE CAREFULLY ME” engraved. The message said everything about her fears regarding her husband's taste for speed.

Credit: Wrist enthusiast

The dial of this watch is a so-called “exotic” dial: Art Deco-style numerals, sub-dials bordered in a contrasting color, and a red seconds track. Rolex struggled to sell it at the time. It was precisely because Newman was photographed wearing this watch, notably in Italian magazines, that collectors eventually dubbed all Daytonas equipped with this dial, from references 6239 to 6265, as the “Paul Newman.” Newman himself was mostly amused by its accuracy: he would bet his friends that his Daytona was more precise than their watches, calling the speaking clock to settle the score.

One afternoon in the summer of 1984, at the family estate in Westport, Connecticut, James Cox, then-boyfriend of Newman's daughter Nell, was helping to repair a treehouse. Newman asked him for the time. Cox did not have a watch. The actor handed him his own. Cox wore it for years without a second thought, before realizing what he had on his wrist. He was the one who consigned it to Phillips in 2017, donating a large portion of the proceeds to the Nell Newman Foundation. For thirty years, the market had searched for this watch without knowing its whereabouts.

James Cox and Paul Newman

If Newman parted with it so easily, it was because he had just received another Daytona, the one he would keep for a quarter of a century.

Big Red: The Watch of a Lifetime

In 1983, for their 25th wedding anniversary, Joanne Woodward gave him a Daytona reference 6263 with a black dial, white sub-dials, and screw-down pushers. Collectors nicknamed it the “Big Red” because of the DAYTONA inscription printed in large red letters above the 6 o'clock sub-dial. On the caseback, the message had changed tone: “DRIVE SLOWLY JOANNE.”

This was the watch Newman wore the longest and with which he was photographed the most, from 1983 to 2008. That year, hospitalized after surgery, he took it off his wrist and insisted that his youngest daughter, Clea, take it. He passed away a few months later, in September 2008. Twelve years later, Clea Newman Soderlund consigned it to Phillips. On December 12, 2020, with an estimate of over $1 million, the Big Red sold for $5,475,000 to an anonymous collector, the third-highest price ever achieved by a Rolex at the time. A portion of the proceeds was donated to the charitable organizations founded by the couple.

The Last Two, and What They Say About the Market

The first was not a gift from Joanne, but a trophy. In 1995, Rolex named Newman “Motorsports Man of the Year” at the 24 Hours of Daytona and presented him with a Daytona 16520, the so-called “Zenith” generation because its movement was derived from a caliber by the Le Locle manufacture. The caseback is engraved with this distinction. Newman himself put it up for sale as early as 1999, at an Antiquorum auction dedicated to celebrity memorabilia.

The second is the last one Joanne gave him, around 2006: a white gold Daytona 116519 with a black dial on a leather strap, powered by the in-house caliber 4130 developed by Rolex. It was the only precious metal Daytona Newman ever owned, and he still used it to time his track laps. The message on the back had become almost a plea: “DRIVE VERY SLOWLY JOANNE.”

Both watches went under the hammer together at Sotheby’s in New York on June 9, 2023, and each surpassed the million-dollar mark, fetching approximately $1.14 million for the Zenith and $1.08 million for the white gold model. In total, Newman's four Daytonas have brought in over $25 million at auction.

These figures make perfect sense when compared to market prices. According to our data, a white gold Daytona 116509, the metal bracelet version from the same generation as Newman's 116519, currently trades for around €38,000. A steel Daytona 116520, which succeeded the Zenith, goes for around €23,000. Newman's watch therefore sold for roughly twenty-five times the price of an equivalent model. What people are paying for is not the gold or the movement, but the provenance: a documented history, an engraving, a direct link to the family.

<figure style="margin:1.5em 0;max-width:600px">

<a href="https://www.ostermanwatch.com/category/Watch/Rolex/Daytona/116509?utm_source=embed" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><img src="https://www.ostermanwatch.com/embed/montre/116509.png?theme=light" alt="Rolex Daytona 116509, Osterman Watch market value" width="600" style="width:100%;height:auto;border:0;border-radius:12px" loading="lazy"></a>

<figcaption style="font:13px/1.4 system-ui,sans-serif;color:#6b6b78;margin-top:6px">Source: <a href="https://www.ostermanwatch.com/category/Watch/Rolex/Daytona/116509">Rolex Daytona 116509, Osterman Watch market value</a> · Osterman Watch</figcaption>

</figure>

This is also the lesson of the 6239. Before 2017, a fine-quality “Paul Newman” Daytona was already expensive, but the New York sale put the entire vintage chronograph segment under the spotlight. Even today, the Daytona remains the driving force behind our chronograph index and one of the pillars of the Rolex 25 index. To track the market value of current Daytonas, all our references are gathered on the Daytona page and the Rolex page.

Newman was never a watch collector. He wore four, gave away two, and sold one. But through them, Joanne Woodward's voice is heard, growing increasingly urgent over the years: carefully, slowly, very slowly.